The New England Patriots, a team long associated with success under the leadership of Bill Belichick, have made some puzzling decisions in the post-Belichick era. One of the most glaring missteps has been the signing and subsequent release of wide receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster after just one season, a move that casts doubt on the team’s current evaluation process.
Re-Signing Belichick’s Acquisitions
In the aftermath of Belichick’s departure, the Patriots have made a series of moves to re-sign several players that were originally brought in under his tenure. This strategy has, in some respects, bolstered Belichick’s reputation as a sharp evaluator of talent, as the team’s willingness to bring back his recruits suggests confidence in his personnel decisions.
However, the recent release of JuJu Smith-Schuster has revealed a significant error in judgment by the current management, tarnishing the image of infallibility that Belichick had built over his career.
The JuJu Smith-Schuster Experiment
JuJu Smith-Schuster’s time with the Patriots was brief and, by most accounts, underwhelming. The team signed him to a three-year deal worth $25 million, including $16 million guaranteed. Of that, $7 million was committed as his salary for the 2024 season, making the decision to cut him after just one year an expensive mistake.
| Player | Contract Duration | Contract Value | Guaranteed Money | 2023 Stats |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JuJu Smith-Schuster | 3 years | $25 million | $16 million | 29 catches, 260 yards, 1 TD |
The Missed Opportunity with Jakobi Meyers
Before signing Smith-Schuster, the Patriots made a controversial decision not to retain Jakobi Meyers, a player who had developed within their system after being signed as an undrafted free agent in 2019. Meyers, who expressed a desire to stay in New England, ultimately left due to a stalled negotiation over a $1 million difference on a three-year contract.
Meyers went on to sign with the Las Vegas Raiders, securing a deal worth $33 million over three years. In his first season with the Raiders, Meyers delivered a strong performance, recording 71 catches for 807 yards and 10 total touchdowns.
| Player | Contract Duration | Contract Value | Guaranteed Money | 2023 Stats |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jakobi Meyers | 3 years | $33 million | Not specified | 71 catches, 807 yards, 10 TDs |
A Costly Gamble
In hindsight, the Patriots’ decision to let Meyers walk and replace him with Smith-Schuster has proven to be a costly gamble. While Smith-Schuster’s contract was slightly cheaper, the value derived from his on-field performance was significantly lower. The team essentially traded away a proven, reliable receiver for a fresh face who failed to meet expectations.
The situation underscores a recurring issue during Belichick’s tenure: the Patriots’ struggles in evaluating and developing wide receiver talent. This latest episode serves as a reminder that even a franchise as storied as the Patriots is not immune to personnel misjudgments.
Moving Forward
As the Patriots navigate this new era without Belichick, the challenge lies in rectifying these errors and making more astute decisions in the future. The release of Smith-Schuster may be a lesson learned, but it also leaves the team searching for answers as they rebuild their roster and strive to regain their former dominance.
The spotlight will be on the Patriots’ front office to see how they address these shortcomings and whether they can maintain the legacy of excellence that Belichick left behind.
More from NFL Wisdom Imbibe: