8 Rookies with the Most to Prove in the 2024 NFL Preseason

As the 2024 NFL preseason kicks off, several rookies find themselves under a significant spotlight. While preseason games and the stats accrued in those matchups don’t count towards the regular season, a strong first impression is crucial for these first-year players looking to secure a roster spot and build confidence within their organizations.

1. Caleb Williams, QB, Chicago Bears

• Background: The top pick in April’s draft, Caleb Williams is expected to transform the Bears into a perennial contender.
• Current Situation: Williams didn’t play in Chicago’s opening preseason game against the Houston Texans.
• Expectations: His ability to lead the offense with precision in subsequent preseason games will be key. Coach Matt Eberflus emphasized the importance of “moving the chains and prioritizing the football” to build confidence before Week 1.

2. Jayden Daniels, QB, Washington Commanders

• Training Camp Performance: The No. 2 overall pick, Daniels has had a good first training camp.
• Role: Expected to be the starter, Daniels’ task is to captain a new-look Commanders offense.
• Key Focus: He needs to demonstrate his understanding of offensive progressions and protections. Coach Dan Quinn is taking a slow approach, highlighting Daniels’ need to show his command of the new system.

3. Quinyon Mitchell, CB, Philadelphia Eagles

• Draft Position: Selected 22nd overall by the Eagles.
• Team Needs: Philadelphia struggled defensively last season, particularly in man coverage.
• Expectations: Mitchell’s elite athletic profile and man-coverage skills put him in a position to start immediately. However, he must quickly adapt to the NFL’s speed and complexity to meet the team’s Super Bowl aspirations.

4. Xavier Legette, WR, Carolina Panthers

• Opportunity: Legette has the chance to become Carolina’s top perimeter target.
• Team Dynamics: The Panthers’ offense is undergoing changes with new head coach Dave Canales.
• Player Development: Legette must quickly evolve into a dynamic playmaker. His chemistry with QB Bryce Young is crucial, with Young noting, “That combination of size, speed, how explosive he is… I’m super excited.”

5. Keon Coleman, WR, Buffalo Bills

• Team Changes: With Gabriel Davis and Stefon Diggs no longer on the roster, Coleman needs to fill a significant void.
• Expectations: Coleman, the No. 33 overall pick, is expected to become QB Josh Allen’s favorite target. His 6’4″ frame and explosiveness should help him assume this role quickly.
• Team Performance: To reach their potential, the Bills need Coleman to excel in the preseason and beyond.

6. Marshawn Kneeland, EDGE, Dallas Cowboys

• Depth Chart Impact: The injury to Sam Williams (torn ACL) has elevated Kneeland’s role.
• Initial Role: Originally projected to be a rotational player, Kneeland now sits behind stars Micah Parsons and DeMarcus Lawrence.
• Player Focus: Kneeland must prove his worth as both a run defender and an improving pass rusher to help keep the defensive line fresh and effective.

7. Joe Alt, OT, Los Angeles Chargers

• Position Transition: Alt is switching from left to right tackle, a challenging move for any rookie.
• Team Needs: Protecting QB Justin Herbert is crucial, and Alt must adapt quickly to his new role.
• Expectations: His ability to play to his full potential alongside Rashawn Slater could form one of the NFL’s premier tackle tandems. Any struggles in transition could impact the Chargers’ offensive success.

8. Tyler Guyton, OT, Dallas Cowboys

• Team Transition: With Tyron Smith now with the Jets, Guyton steps in as the Cowboys’ left tackle.
• Athleticism: Known for his exceptional athleticism, Guyton’s ability to adapt to the left side is vital.
• Key Task: Protecting Dak Prescott’s blindside is his top priority. While his footwork and agility provide a solid foundation, any prolonged adjustment period could hinder Dallas’ offensive performance.

The 2024 NFL preseason is crucial for these rookies. Their ability to meet expectations will not only determine their immediate futures but also significantly impact their teams’ performance and strategies for the upcoming season.