The Pittsburgh Steelers enter the 2026 offseason in familiar limbo at quarterback, waiting on Aaron Rodgers‘ decision about returning for what would be his age-43 season. Rodgers, who joined Pittsburgh in 2025 after a brief stint elsewhere, has been non-committal amid swirling retirement rumors—no firm deadline exists, and talks remain stalled. GM Omar Khan has expressed openness to Rodgers’ return, but the team can’t afford to stand pat indefinitely with backups Mason Rudolph and Will Howard as the only current options.
NFL Wisdom Imbibe Insight:
The proposed Anthony Richardson trade reflects a growing NFL trend: buying low on high-upside quarterbacks. For Pittsburgh, the gamble could secure a long-term successor if Aaron Rodgers retires. For Indianapolis, moving on would reset the roster and recover draft capital. In today’s quarterback-driven league, even risky talent rarely stays on the market long.
This uncertainty has fueled speculation about contingency plans, including a potential trade for Anthony Richardson from the Indianapolis Colts. A recent fan/proposal pitch (circulating on sites like Dose.ca and echoed in Steelers media) suggests:
- Steelers receive: QB Anthony Richardson
- Colts receive: 2026 fourth-round pick (No. 121 overall)
The low cost—a mid-round selection—makes it an intriguing low-risk flier for Pittsburgh, especially given Richardson’s original draft capital (No. 4 overall in 2023).
Richardson’s Rocky Colts Tenure
Selected fourth overall by Indianapolis, Richardson flashed elite athleticism but struggled with consistency and injuries. Over his first three seasons (2023–2025), he started just 15 games:
- Stats: 177/350 passing (50.6% completion), ~2,400 yards, 11 TDs, 13 INTs.
- Rushing impact: 634 yards and 10 TDs on the ground, showcasing his dual-threat upside.
Accuracy issues and turnovers plagued him, and he lost the starting job to Daniel Jones in 2025. Jones earned a two-year, $88 million extension, closing the door on Richardson’s path in Indy. The Colts granted him permission to seek a trade in late February 2026 (per reports from The Athletic, ESPN, and NFL.com), with multiple suitors interested but no deal imminent. His 2026 cap hit (~$10.8 million) adds motivation for Indy to move him, though leverage remains low.
Why This Trade Could Appeal to the Steelers
- Bridge/Development Scenario: If Rodgers returns for one more year, Richardson could sit, learn, and develop under a veteran coach/system—potentially thriving in Pittsburgh’s run-heavy scheme.
- Upside at Low Cost: At just 23 (turns 24 in May 2026), Richardson’s arm strength and mobility offer long-term potential. A fourth-rounder is a bargain compared to his draft pedigree.
- QB Depth Need: Beyond Rodgers uncertainty, the Steelers lack a clear franchise successor. This move addresses that without mortgaging high picks.
Analysts and insiders (e.g., Kay Adams on podcasts) have floated Pittsburgh as a logical landing spot, emphasizing Richardson’s fit if he gets proper coaching. Steelers media outlets like Steelers Depot and Still Curtain have discussed similar scenarios as “win-win” or “polarizing but intriguing.”
Why the Colts Might Accept (or Push for More)
Indy has limited leverage—teams know both sides want a split. A fourth-rounder feels aggressive from Pittsburgh’s perspective (some evaluators peg Richardson’s value at a Day 3 pick, like a fifth-rounder). The Colts would likely jump at it to recoup assets and clear cap space. However, if other suitors (e.g., Vikings, Packers) emerge with better offers, Indy could hold out.
Realistic Outlook
No deal appears close as of mid-March 2026—negotiations continue with “interested” teams, but nothing imminent. The Steelers have been active elsewhere in free agency (e.g., adding WRs and depth), but QB remains the priority. If Rodgers retires or delays, Pittsburgh could pivot aggressively.
This pitch is a smart, low-stakes idea on paper: cheap upside for a team in transition, salary relief and draft capital for Indy. Whether it materializes depends on Rodgers’ final call and competing bids—but in a QB-needy league, don’t count it out. For now, it’s a compelling hypothetical that aligns with Pittsburgh’s need for a post-Rodgers plan.
Recommended for you: