As the New Orleans Saints gear up for the 2024 NFL season, one of the most intriguing storylines has been the quarterback competition between Jake Haener and Spencer Rattler. With Derek Carr solidified as the starter, the battle for the backup quarterback position has been fiercely contested throughout training camp and the preseason. However, this battle isn’t just about 2024—it could very well shape the future of the franchise.
The Stage Is Set: Preseason Finale Showdown
With Derek Carr sitting out the preseason finale, all eyes are on Haener and Rattler as they vie for the second spot on the depth chart. For the first time this preseason, both quarterbacks will receive an equal amount of playing time, making this game a pivotal moment in their competition.
Preseason Performance Comparison:
| Player | Completion Percentage | Passing Yards | Touchdowns | Interceptions | Rushing Yards |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jake Haener | 63% | 485 | 4 | 1 | 45 |
| Spencer Rattler | 60% | 460 | 3 | 2 | 30 |
Key Observations:
- Haener has demonstrated poise in the pocket, with a slightly higher completion rate and an ability to extend plays with his legs.
- Rattler has shown flashes of brilliance, particularly with his deep-ball accuracy, but his decision-making has led to a couple of costly interceptions.
The Preseason Finale: A Crucial Test
As the Saints approach their final preseason game, the strategy is clear: each quarterback will likely play one half. The first quarterback on the field will get the opportunity to work with players higher on the depth chart, potentially indicating who is currently favored in the competition. However, this does not necessarily mean the battle is over; it’s just one more chapter in a storyline that could continue into the regular season.
Potential Scenarios:
| Scenario | Implication |
|---|---|
| Haener Starts with First Unit | Haener may be slightly ahead in the competition, gaining valuable reps with the starting offense. |
| Rattler Starts with First Unit | Rattler is given the chance to prove he can lead the team, potentially indicating a close race. |
| Both QBs Play Equal Halves | The battle remains too close to call, with both quarterbacks getting a fair shot with different units. |
| One QB Significantly Outperforms the Other | This could tip the scales decisively, potentially locking in the backup role for the winner. |
Long-Term Implications: Beyond 2024
While the immediate focus is on securing the backup spot for 2024, this competition holds greater significance for the Saints’ future. Derek Carr is the present, but the winner of this battle could be the franchise quarterback of tomorrow.
Long-Term Potential:
| Player | Strengths | Areas for Improvement | Potential Ceiling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jake Haener | Strong pocket presence, accurate passer | Needs to improve deep-ball consistency | Future franchise leader |
| Spencer Rattler | Elite arm talent, mobility | Decision-making under pressure | Pro Bowl-caliber quarterback |
This preseason is merely the beginning of what could be a long-term rivalry between Haener and Rattler. Whoever emerges as the backup this season will have a leg up in next year’s competition, and potentially, the opportunity to succeed Carr as the Saints’ starting quarterback in the future.
Final Thoughts: The Saints’ Quarterback Future
As the Saints head into their final preseason game, the Haener vs. Rattler battle remains one of the most compelling stories in the NFL. While the preseason finale will offer significant insights into who might start the season as Carr’s understudy, the real significance lies in the long-term potential each quarterback brings to the table.
The journey to becoming the Saints’ franchise quarterback is far from over. Whether it’s Haener or Rattler who steps up in the short term, both will continue to fight for the chance to lead this team in the future. Saints fans should keep a close eye on this battle—not just for this season, but for what it could mean in the years to come.